Teacher- and Student-Centered Learning in a Hierarchical, Collectivist Context
نویسندگان
doi
10.22062/sdme.2026.201519.1630چکیده
Background: The growing trend of student-centered learning (SCL) in Asia demands specific attention to existing cultural characteristics and their effects on learning. Objectives: This study aimed to assess and compare the effectiveness of teacher-centered learning (TCL) and various SCL approaches in enhancing Indonesian undergraduate medical students’ knowledge in contexts characterized by hierarchical and collectivist values. Additionally, we aimed to measure students’ satisfaction with learning through the respective learning methods and to explore the learning experiences underlying their satisfaction (or dissatisfaction) with them. Methods: A total of 164 2nd year undergraduate medical students from one private school participated in this experimental, mixed-method study using a concurrent triangulation design. Participants were divided into four groups: TCL, flipped classroom (FC), question-based discussion (QBD), and peer-assisted learning (PAL). Effectiveness was measured using a post-test. Students’ satisfaction data were gathered quantitatively and qualitatively using a questionnaire. Quantitative data were analyzed using the Kruskal-Wallis test, followed by a post-hoc test. A p-value of ≤0.05 was considered statistically significant. Qualitative data on students’ satisfaction were analyzed using an inductive coding approach to thematic analysis. Results: Post-test scores show no statistically significant difference between the TCL and SCL methods (p=0.334). Students’ satisfaction with the TCL method was higher compared to the SCL methods (p≤0.05). Two main themes were identified: positive learning experiences and challenges. Conclusion: TCL and SCL are comparably effective in increasing undergraduate medical students’ knowledge in Indonesia. Although TCL showed higher student satisfaction, a combination of TCL with PAL and FC may be worth considering.